Much like my nearly unreadable teenage penmanship has deteriorated across a quarter-century of digital document creation, my instincts to halt and record progress in a game diminished. I attribute this to the rise of automatic saving, save points, console quick-resume features, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I instinctively save obsessively just in case disaster strikes. But I’m not perfect. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I discovered a vital reminder eight hours into the recently released Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: you must still smash that save button.
Many years had gone by since I last played a classic Pokémon title — as I skipped the GBA era, the Johto region games may have been the most recent traditional Pokémon journey I completed. Therefore, I was excited to spend the asking price for a trip down memory lane to the land of the original 151, and a quest to catch those classic 151 pocket monsters. I immediately snapped back to the glory days. During a handful of gaming sessions, I was catching bugs, found a Pikachu in Viridian Forest, defeated the first Gym Leader with ease, invested in the useless fish from the salesman in the Pokémon Center, and journeyed through Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.
The fatal flaw: I failed to save even once! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
Jigglypuff will never be friends with the Mankey I caught.
The catastrophe occurred one evening when I wasn't even playing… and as my daughter grabbed the Switch for a swift 30 minutes of Pokémon Z-A instead, shutting down my session in the process. As we all know (as I should have known…) launching a different title on the console forces the closure of the active game. Your data is only preserved when an autosave triggers or after a manual save prior to changing games. My mistake.
The Progression of Saving Progress: From Deliberate to Seamless
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so seamless most players barely notice it, as a true “next-generation” innovation. Whereas the early computer game Zork had one of the earliest save functions in a game, the original NES Legend of Zelda is often credited as a landmark achievement because players no longer felt totally ruined by an in-game fail because of persistent memory saves on NES cartridges. Obviously, you still had to remember to save. (And once you erred), you’d never forget. During the nineties, memory cards on consoles such as the PS1 popularized saving but remained precarious; forgetting to save (or losing a card) meant losing significant playtime. Titles such as Resident Evil took it further by transforming saving into an item to be managed.
Modern autosave, that eroded my manual save habit my retro gaming session so completely, took hold in the early 2000s. Halo: Combat Evolved pioneered seamless respawn points as the Call of Duty series honed the approach to smooth difficulty and eliminate repetition. As experiences became more vast — and more open-world — devs cracked the code of persistent, invisible saving and, eventually, the ultimate convenience of suspend/resume.
Pokémon's Own Journey: From Manual Ritual to Modern Convenience
Curiously, this iconic franchise offers a clear snapshot of that technological evolution. For a long time, saving in a Pokémon game was a deliberate choice: gamers were conditioned to hit “Save” ahead of powering down their handheld console. A major change arrived in Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the series introduced autosave (initially optional), marking a major philosophical change within one of the industry's most most tradition-bound franchises.
I can admit failure: Countless hours spent in Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles totally eroded my manual save reflex. I am still wary in some cases — I won’t even gamble bailing mid-run in a challenging indie title despite being aware it saves progress automatically — but whether it’s been the lengthy gap since I last invested classic gaming mechanics, or I'm simply pampered, the thought never entered my mind to manually save before redocking. Seven-year-old me would have been more diligent so catastrophically.
The Result: A Discouraged Player
I have not picked up FireRed since my save debacle. When I saw the title screen again to see I had only Squirtle on my roster, a wave of exhaustion hit me. My personal status: Burned.
Maybe I’ll go back… or maybe I’ll stick with the countless modern titles dropping every day that kindly assume I am incapable of manual saving. However, my affection for classic games persists. On occasions when I can convince my child to take a break from auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we have been cooperatively playing some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those classic titles skipped saving altogether opting instead for lengthy password codes. Therefore, if I meet an explosive end, the setback is minimal. For now, that’s comfort.